| Father | Male Courtland Philip Livingston Butler |
| Born | 8 Mar 1813 | Clinton, NY  |
| Died | 9 Aug 1891 | Columbus, OH |
| Buried | ||
| Married | 16 Dec 1840 | Buffalo, NY |
| Father | ||
| Mother | ||
| Mother | Female Elizabeth Slade Pierce |
| Born | 22 Mar 1822 | Providence, RI |
| Died | 1 Mar 1901 | Columbus, OH |
| Buried | ||
| Father | Levi Pierce | F3505 Group Sheet | |
| Mother | Betsey S. Wheeler | F3505 Group Sheet | |
| Child 1 | Female Mary Elizabeth Butler |
| Born | 15 Jul 1850 | Columbus, OH |
| Died | 16 Jan 1897 | Columbus, OH |
| Buried | ||
| Spouse | Robert Emmet Sheldon | F3507 | |
| Married | 24 Feb 1869 | Columbus, OH |
