1751 - 1786 (35 years)
1775-1834
| David Tuttle | |
| B: | 5 Apr 1775 |
| Willington, Tolland County, Connecticut | |
| D: | 5 Jun 1834 |
| New York | |
1777-1851
| Polly Fisk | |
| B: | 1777 |
| Willington Hill, Tolland County, Connecticut | |
| M: | 10 Sep 1798 |
| Peru, Berkshire County, Massachusetts | |
| D: | Dec 1851 |
|
1751-1786
| Nathan Tuttle | |
| B: | 1751 |
| Willington, Tolland County, Connecticut | |
| D: | 1786 |
| Coventry, Tolland County, Connecticut | |
1753-Unknown
| Priscilla Hall | |
| B: | 27 Jan 1753 |
| Mansfield, Tolland County, Connecticut | |
| M: | 13 Jun 1771 |
| Willington, Tolland County, Connecticut | |
| D: | Unknown |
