1740 - 1788 (48 years)
| Cornelius Toothaker | |
| B: | 25 Sep 1790 |
| Harpswell, Cumberland County, Maine | |
| D: | 22 Aug 1868 |
| Litchfield, Kennebec County, Maine | |
1794-1883
| Hannah M. Gray | |
| B: | Apr 1794 |
| Harpswell, Cumberland County, Maine | |
| M: | Abt 1811 |
| Harpswell, Cumberland County, Maine | |
| D: | 13 Aug 1883 |
| Richmond, Sagadahoc County, Maine | |
| Ebenezer Toothaker, III | |
| B: | 1766 |
| Harpswell, Cumberland County, Maine | |
| D: | 1856 |
1764-1857
| Phebe Hinks | |
| B: | 15 Jan 1764 |
| Truro, Barnstable County, Massachusetts | |
| M: | 30 Sep 1788 |
| Harpswell, Cumberland County, Maine | |
| D: | 26 Aug 1857 |
| Harpswell, Cumberland County, Maine | |
|
| Ebenezer Toothaker, Jr. | |
| B: | 1740 |
| Harpswell, Cumberland County, Maine | |
| D: | 1788 |
-Unknown
| Miss [--?--] | |
| M: | Bef 1766 |
| D: | Unknown |
