1683 - 1727 (43 years)
| Jonathan Atwater 1721-1764 |
| Jonathan Atwater | |
| B: | 10 Mar 1720/21 |
| New Haven, New Haven County, Connecticut | |
| D: | 24 Aug 1764 |
| New Haven, New Haven County, Connecticut | |
Sarah Beach 1727-1803 |
| Sarah Beach | |
| B: | 25 Mar 1727 |
| Wallingford, New Haven County, Connecticut | |
| M: | 23 Jan 1744/45 |
| New Haven, New Haven County, Connecticut | |
| D: | 17 Jul 1803 |
| New Haven, New Haven County, Connecticut | |
|
| David Atwater 1683-1727 |
| David Atwater | |
| B: | 5 Aug 1683 |
| New Haven, New Haven County, Connecticut Colony, New England | |
| D: | 1 May 1727 |
| New Haven, New Haven County, Connecticut Colony, New England | |
| Tabitha Holt 1684-1743 |
| Tabitha Holt | |
| B: | 30 Jan 1683/84 |
| Branford, New Haven County, Connecticut | |
| D: | 4 Oct 1743 |
| New Haven, New Haven County, Connecticut Colony, New England | |
